Current:Home > reviewsTrump’s lawyers file challenges to Washington election subversion case, calling it unconstitutional -Wealth Legacy Solutions
Trump’s lawyers file challenges to Washington election subversion case, calling it unconstitutional
View
Date:2025-04-14 17:22:53
WASHINGTON (AP) — Lawyers for Donald Trump are raising new challenges to the federal election subversion case against him, telling a judge that the indictment should be dismissed because it violates the former president’s free speech rights and represents a vindictive prosecution.
The motions filed late Monday in the case charging the Republican with plotting to overturn the results of the 2020 election he lost are on top of a pending argument by defense attorneys that he is immune from federal prosecution for actions taken within his official role as president.
Special counsel Jack Smith’s team urged a judge last week to reject that argument and is expected to do the same for the latest motions. It is routine for defendants to ask a judge to dismiss the charges against them, but such requests are rarely granted. In Trump’s case, though, the challenges to the indictment could at a minimum force a delay in a prosecution that is set for trial in Washington next March.
Taken together, the motions cut to the heart of some of Trump’s most oft-repeated public defenses: that he is being prosecuted for political reasons by the Biden administration Justice Department and that he was within his First Amendment rights to challenge the outcome of the election and to allege that it had been tainted by fraud — a finding not supported by courts across the country or even by Trump’s own attorney general.
The lawyers claim prosecutors are attempting to criminalize political speech and political advocacy, arguing that First Amendment protections extend even to statements “made in advocating for government officials to act on one’s views.” They said the prosecution team “cannot criminalize claims that the 2020 Presidential election was stolen” nor “impose its views on a disputed political question” like the election’s integrity.
“The fact that the indictment alleges that the speech at issue was supposedly, according to the prosecution, ‘false’ makes no difference,” the defense wrote. “Under the First Amendment, each individual American participating in a free marketplace of ideas — not the federal Government — decides for him or herself what is true and false on great disputed social and political questions.”
Smith’s team conceded at the outset of the four-count indictment that Trump could indeed lawfully challenge his loss to Democrat Joe Biden but said his actions went far beyond that, including by illegally conspiring to block the official counting of electoral votes by Congress on Jan. 6, 2021, when rioters who supported him stormed the Capitol and caused a violent clash with police and a delay to the proceedings. A spokesman for Smith declined to comment on Tuesday.
The defense lawyers also contend that Trump, the early front-runner for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination, is being prosecuted for vindictive and political reasons, alleging that “Biden’s publicly stated objective is to use the criminal justice system to incapacitate President Trump, his main political rival and the leading candidate in the upcoming election.” It says the Justice Department appointed Smith as special counsel last year as a way to “insulate Biden and his supporters from scrutiny of their obvious and illegal bias.”
Trump’s lawyers are also asking to strike from the indictment references to the pro-Trump mob’s attack on the Capitol on Jan. 6 because they say prosecutors have not accused the then-president of inciting the riot.
“Allegations in the indictment relating to these actions, when President Trump has not been charged with responsibility for them, is highly prejudicial and inflammatory because members of the jury may wrongfully impute fault to President Trump for these actions,” his attorneys wrote.
___
Richer reported from Boston.
veryGood! (189)
Related
- NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
- Horoscopes Today, December 9, 2023
- Anna Cardwell, 'Here Comes Honey Boo Boo' star, dies at 29 following cancer battle
- Man arrested, charged with murder in death of 16-year-old Texas high school student
- Buckingham Palace staff under investigation for 'bar brawl'
- Egyptians vote for president, with el-Sissi certain to win
- Eagles' Tush Push play is borderline unstoppable. Will it be banned next season?
- Agreeing to agree: Everyone must come to consensus at COP28 climate talks, toughening the process
- NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
- New Mexico court reverses ruling that overturned a murder conviction on speedy trial violations
Ranking
- Man can't find second winning lottery ticket, sues over $394 million jackpot, lawsuit says
- Recognizing the signs of postpartum depression
- The Golden Globe nominations are coming. Here’s everything you need to know
- 7 puppies rescued in duct taped box in Arkansas cemetery; reward offered for information
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Former Titans TE Frank Wycheck, key cog in 'Music City Miracle,' dies after fall at home
- 'SNL' host Adam Driver plays piano, tells Santa 'wokeness' killed Han Solo in monologue
- 'Alone and malnourished': Orphaned sea otter gets a new home at Chicago's Shedd Aquarium
Recommendation
Nearly 400 USAID contract employees laid off in wake of Trump's 'stop work' order
Los Angeles Chargers QB Justin Herbert suffers right index fracture vs. Denver Broncos
7 puppies rescued in duct taped box in Arkansas cemetery; reward offered for information
Live updates | Israel says it’s prepared to fight for months to defeat Hamas
NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
Drug lords go on killing spree to hunt down corrupt officers who stole shipment in Mexico’s Tijuana
Micah Parsons listed on Cowboys' injury report with illness ahead of Eagles game
Key evidence in the disappearance and death of millionaire Andreen McDonald